Marketing Strategy & OperationsExplainer3 min readUpdated September 2026

Ahrefs KD vs Semrush KD: Why the Scores Disagree

Ahrefs keyword difficulty and Semrush keyword difficulty disagree because they estimate different things. Ahrefs bases its score mainly on the backlinks pointing to top-ranking pages, while Semrush blends link data with other authority signals. Neither number predicts your rankings on its own.

Treat both as a rough ranking of how hard a keyword is compared with others in the same tool. Then check the search results yourself before committing to any article.

Vendors Covered in this Article

Disclosure: We may earn a commission if you buy through some links on this page. It doesn't change what we recommend.

What does each tool's difficulty score actually measure?

Both use a 0 to 100 scale, and both are estimates. As the vendors describe it, Ahrefs KD is driven by the number of referring domains linking to the pages currently in the top 10. Semrush's Keyword Difficulty percentage also looks at the authority of the ranking pages and domains, not only link counts. Methods change, so confirm the current description in each tool's help pages.

That difference matters. A keyword where the top pages have few links but sit on very strong domains may look easy in a links-only score and harder in a blended one.

Why do the same keywords get different scores?

Several factors compound:

  • Different formulas: links-only versus blended signals, as above.
  • Different link databases: each tool crawls the web independently, so they count different referring domains for the same page.
  • Different SERP snapshots: results vary by location, device, and the moment of the crawl.
  • Different keyword handling: tools group close variants differently, so volume and difficulty may describe slightly different sets of queries.
  • Different scaling: a 40 in one tool isn't the same effort as a 40 in the other.

Say a keyword shows 35 in one tool and 58 in the other. That gap doesn't mean one is wrong. It means you have to look at the results page to see why.

A worked example: two keywords, two tools

Say keyword A shows a score of 28 in Ahrefs and 45 in Semrush, while keyword B shows 30 in one and 31 in the other.

Keyword B is the easier call, because both tools agree. Keyword A needs a look. The lower Ahrefs score suggests the top pages have modest link profiles, and the higher Semrush score suggests those pages sit on strong, established domains. Open the results page. If a small site with few links holds a top-five spot, you can probably compete. If every result is a household-name publisher, the Semrush number is closer to the truth for a new site.

Write down your call and revisit it after publishing. A small log of predicted difficulty versus actual position is the best calibration you'll get.

How to use either score to pick keywords

A workable process:

  1. Choose one tool for shortlisting and stick with it, so the scores are consistent.
  2. Filter to a difficulty band your site can plausibly compete in. If your site is new, start at the low end and raise it as your authority grows.
  3. Open the results page for each finalist and note who's ranking: big publishers, competitors, forums, or small sites.
  4. Check whether the ranking pages match the search intent you'd serve.
  5. Look at the link counts to the top three pages. If a small site with few links ranks there, the keyword is likely reachable.
  6. Use the second tool as a tiebreaker for your final picks, not as a replacement.

A site owner can pair this with the low-competition keyword approach for B2B niches.

Why does position matter more than the score?

Difficulty exists because rankings pay off unevenly. Organic click-through rate by position, from a published benchmark, drops from 39.8 percent for position 1 to 18.7 percent for position 2 and 10.2 percent for position 31. By position 10 it falls to 1.6 percent1.

So a keyword rated easy but where you'd realistically land at position 8 may not send much traffic. And a hard keyword might be worth it if you could reach the top three. Use the score to rule things out, then estimate the position you can realistically hit.

Which tool should you trust for B2B keyword research?

Neither is universally better. Ahrefs is often chosen by teams who want to focus on backlink analysis, and Semrush by teams who want research, tracking, and competitor tools together. Pick based on the rest of your workflow. A comparison like Semrush vs Ahrefs vs Moz walks through the tradeoffs.

Whichever you use, validate scores against real results pages, and record what happened after publishing. Over a few months you'll learn how the score maps to your site's actual results, which is worth more than any generic threshold.

Executive Capability Standard

What Good Looks Like

A good keyword decision uses a difficulty score to shortlist, then confirms feasibility by reading the actual results page and its link profile.

Building The Capability (5-Stage Skill Ladder)

1. Learn:Read each tool's own description of how its difficulty score is calculated and note the differences.
2. Do Manually:For ten target keywords, open the results page and record who ranks, their link counts, and whether the intent matches.
3. Delegate:Have a content or SEO specialist prepare a shortlist with difficulty, intent, and estimated position for each keyword.
4. Automate:Set up rank tracking for published keywords so you can compare predicted difficulty to actual position over time.
5. Buy:Subscribe to one research tool and standardize on it for shortlisting.

How to Get Started

Disclosure: We may earn a commission if you buy through some links on this page. It doesn't change what we recommend.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Ahrefs keyword difficulty more accurate than Semrush?

Neither is objectively more accurate, because they measure different things. Ahrefs focuses on backlinks to top pages, while Semrush blends more signals. Choose one for consistent shortlisting and verify with the results page.

What is a good keyword difficulty score for a new site?

There's no fixed cutoff. New sites generally do better starting at the low end of whichever tool's scale, then moving up as they earn links and authority. Check who ranks to see if similar sites appear.

Can a keyword with high difficulty still be worth targeting?

Yes, if it maps closely to a purchase decision and you have a strong page and some authority. Consider a longer, more specific variant first, since it often converts well with less competition.

Should I compare scores across Ahrefs and Semrush?

No. The scales aren't calibrated to each other. Compare keywords within one tool, and treat the second tool's number as a sanity check rather than something to average.

Sources

Where we quote a benchmark, we show its source. Other figures in this guide are estimates or general guidance, so check them against your own numbers.

  1. Organic Search CTR by Google Ranking Position. First Page Sage: Google CTRs by Ranking Position (2026), 2026.

Related Guides