Marketing Operations, MarTech Stack & Lead RoutingPlaybook3 min readUpdated September 2026

How to Warm Up a New Email Sending Domain

A new sending domain has no history with inbox providers, which means the first few weeks of sending determine whether your mail lands in the inbox or the spam folder for months afterward. This is a runbook for warming up a domain gradually instead of sending at full volume from day one and finding out the hard way.

Vendors Covered in this Article

Disclosure: We may earn a commission if you buy through some links on this page. It doesn't change what we recommend.

Before You Send Anything: Authentication Records

Set up SPF, DKIM, and DMARC records for the sending domain before the first email goes out. These records tell inbox providers that mail claiming to be from your domain is actually authorized to send on its behalf, and missing or misconfigured records are one of the most common reasons a new domain struggles regardless of how careful the warmup schedule is. Verify each record with your email platform's built-in checker rather than assuming a copy-pasted DNS entry is correct.

Start With Your Most Engaged Recipients, Not Your Full List

Begin sending to the subscribers most likely to open and click, recent signups, active customers, people who've engaged with your brand elsewhere, rather than your full list. Inbox providers watch engagement signals closely in the first sends from a new domain, and strong early engagement is what builds the reputation that lets you expand volume later. Sending your full list on day one, including contacts who haven't engaged in years, is one of the fastest ways to damage a new domain's reputation before it has any history to fall back on.

For example, suppose your list includes recent signups and active customers, plus a much larger group that hasn't opened anything in a long time. Send only to the first group at the start, and keep the dormant contacts out until the domain has a record of steady engagement. If complaints tick up after a volume increase, treat that as a signal to hold, not as noise to push through. Keep a simple log of each increase and the results that followed it, so a problem can be traced to a specific step instead of guessed at. That log also explains to colleagues why the schedule runs slower than the calendar you first sketched.

Increase Volume Gradually Over Several Weeks

Rather than a single fixed schedule, the underlying principle is to increase sending volume in modest steps, watching engagement and complaint rates after each increase before stepping up again. If open rates drop or complaint rates rise after an increase, hold at the current volume rather than continuing to scale up on schedule regardless of what the data shows. Warmup is a feedback loop, not a fixed calendar, even though it helps to have a rough calendar in mind for planning purposes.

Follow this sequence when warming up a new domain:

  1. Set up SPF, DKIM, and DMARC records for the sending domain and verify each one with your email platform's checker before the first send.
  2. Send first to your most engaged recipients, such as recent signups and active customers, instead of the full list.
  3. Raise sending volume in modest steps, and check engagement and complaint rates after each increase before stepping up again.
  4. Track opens, spam complaints, and bounces for the new domain separately from any established domain you still use.
  5. If open rates fall or complaints rise, hold at the current volume until the numbers recover, then resume the increases.

Watch the Right Signals, Not Just Whether Mail Sends Successfully

A send that completes without an error doesn't mean it landed in the inbox. Track open rates, spam complaint rates, and bounce rates specifically for the new domain, separate from any established sending domain you're still using in parallel. A new sending domain with no history often opens well below the 35.63 percent industry median until its reputation is established1, so don't panic at a lower open rate in the first couple of weeks; watch the trend across the warmup period instead of reacting to any single day's number.

Common Mistakes That Undo a Careful Warmup

Switching sending platforms or IPs partway through a warmup effectively resets the process, since reputation is tied to the specific sending infrastructure, not just the domain name. Sending a single large blast to celebrate hitting a volume milestone, rather than continuing the gradual increase, can undo weeks of careful buildup in one send. And pausing sending for an extended stretch after warmup completes can cause reputation to decay, so keep a consistent baseline of sends going even during slower periods.

What to Do If Reputation Damage Already Happened

If a domain's reputation is already damaged, from too-fast scaling or a bad list, recovery generally means pulling volume back down to your most engaged segment and rebuilding from there, essentially restarting the warmup process rather than pushing through at current volume. This is slower than getting it right the first time, which is the strongest argument for following a careful schedule from the start rather than treating warmup as an optional step to skip when you're in a hurry to launch a campaign.

During recovery, communicate the same discipline internally that you would during an initial warmup, since the temptation to rush back to full volume once metrics start improving is exactly what caused the damage the first time.

Executive Capability Standard

What Good Looks Like

A good warmup process authenticates the domain before sending, starts with the most engaged recipients, increases volume gradually based on engagement data rather than a fixed calendar, and avoids resetting progress with a platform switch or a sudden large send.

Building The Capability (5-Stage Skill Ladder)

1. Learn:Learn how SPF, DKIM, and DMARC work and verify they're correctly configured before your first send from a new domain.
2. Do Manually:Run the first couple of warmup weeks by hand, manually selecting your most engaged segment and watching daily engagement metrics.
3. Delegate:Hand ongoing warmup monitoring to a lifecycle or deliverability-focused team member once the initial schedule is underway.
4. Automate:Use an automation platform like ConvertKit to manage the gradual segment expansion so volume increases don't depend on someone remembering to update send lists.
5. Buy:Bring in a dedicated warmup service like InboxAlly if you're launching several new domains at once or don't have engagement data clean enough to warm up manually.

How to Get Started

Disclosure: We may earn a commission if you buy through some links on this page. It doesn't change what we recommend.

Frequently Asked Questions

How long does domain warmup typically take?

It varies by starting list size and target volume, but plan for several weeks of gradual increases rather than expecting to reach full volume in the first week. Rushing the schedule is the most common reason a warmup doesn't hold.

Should I warm up a new domain even if my old one has good reputation?

Yes. Sending reputation is tied to the specific domain and sending infrastructure, not transferable from an old domain to a new one. Any new sending domain, even from an established sender, needs its own warmup period.

What should I do if my open rates drop during warmup?

Hold at your current sending volume rather than continuing to increase on schedule, and check whether the drop coincides with a shift toward less-engaged recipients. A temporary plateau while you address the underlying cause is better than pushing through and risking a spam folder placement that's harder to reverse.

Sources

Where we quote a benchmark, we show its source. Other figures in this guide are estimates or general guidance, so check them against your own numbers.

  1. Email Open Rate (All Industries). Mailchimp Email Marketing Benchmarks (data updated Dec 2023), 2023.

Related Guides