A Checklist for Reviewing a Creative Agency's RFP
Most agency RFP scoring sheets reward the same things every agency is good at describing: process, past clients, and a nice deck. They say very little about whether the agency will actually produce creative that performs for your specific product and budget.
This is a shorter list, built around the parts of an RFP response that are hardest to fake and most predictive of whether the relationship works six months in.
Vendors Covered in this Article
Disclosure: We may earn a commission if you buy through some links on this page. It doesn't change what we recommend.
Ask for the process, not the pitch
Every agency response includes a slide about their "proven process." Ask instead for a walkthrough of one real project from brief to final asset, including where it went sideways. An agency that can talk through a creative that underperformed and what they changed is telling you more about how they'll work with you than any process diagram.
Ask specifically how many rounds of revision are included before overage fees kick in, and get that in writing. This is the single most common source of budget disputes once work starts.
Also ask what happens when a brief changes mid-production, since it usually does at least once on any real campaign. An agency with a clear, reasonable answer (a defined change-request process, a rough sense of what triggers a new quote) is easier to work with than one that says it's handled case by case, which usually means it's negotiated after the fact when you're in the weakest position to push back.
Put these questions to every agency in writing before you score anything:
- Can you walk us through one real project from brief to final asset, including a creative that underperformed and what you changed?
- How many revision rounds are included before overage fees begin, and where is that written in the agreement?
- What is your process when a brief changes mid-production, and what triggers a new quote?
- Who will write, shoot and edit our creative by name and role, and how much of that work is subcontracted?
- Can you share a sample report that separates creative performance from media performance?
Check who actually does the work, not who's in the pitch
The team in the RFP meeting is rarely the team that ends up on your account. Ask for the names and roles of the people who will actually write, shoot, and edit your creative, and ask how much of that work is done in-house versus subcontracted.
A subcontracted editor or freelance director isn't automatically a problem, but you want to know before you sign, not when a deliverable slips because a subcontractor's schedule changed and nobody told you.
Ask, too, how many other accounts your specific team is staffed on at the same time. An agency can be well-resourced overall and still put your account behind two larger clients internally; a direct question about current workload usually gets a more honest answer than asking about capacity in the abstract.
Reporting: what they'll actually show you, and how often
Ask for a sample report, not a description of their reporting capability. Look specifically at whether it separates creative performance (hook rate, watch time, click-through by variant) from media performance, and whether it flags underperforming assets on its own or waits for you to notice.
The cost-per-click your paid channels are running should be visible in that reporting too; the current cross-industry average on Google Ads is around $5.261, which is a useful baseline to compare against whatever the agency reports back.
Pricing structures, and where the real cost hides
A flat retainer, a project fee, and a percentage-of-spend model each shift incentives differently. A percentage-of-spend agency has less reason to recommend cutting an underperforming campaign, so if that's the model, ask directly how they've handled that tension with a past client.
Get clarity on what counts as a "deliverable" versus a billable extra: additional edit passes, extra aspect ratios for different platforms, and usage rights beyond the original placement are common places where the quoted price and the actual invoice drift apart.
Where RFP scoring usually goes wrong
Scoring every category equally is the most common mistake. Past client logos and case studies matter far less than whether the agency's actual production process fits your timeline and budget, so weight the process, team, and reporting sections heavily and treat the credentials section as a filter, not a tiebreaker.
The second mistake is skipping a reference call with a client who left the agency, not just one they're still working with. Ask that former client directly why the relationship ended; the answer usually tells you more than three glowing references combined.
The third is letting the RFP process drag on for months while the scoring criteria quietly shift underneath it. Set the criteria before you send the RFP, share them with every agency so the responses are actually comparable, and hold yourself to a decision date. A search that runs too long usually ends with whichever agency followed up most recently, not the one that scored best on paper.
What Good Looks Like
A good RFP evaluation weighs actual production process, named team members, and a real sample report more heavily than case study logos, and it includes at least one reference call with a client who left the agency.
Building The Capability (5-Stage Skill Ladder)
How to Get Started
Disclosure: We may earn a commission if you buy through some links on this page. It doesn't change what we recommend.
Gamma is a reasonable way to turn your RFP scorecard and notes into a clean summary for whoever signs off on the final decision.
If you're presenting the finalist comparison to a founder or board, Prezi's format works well for walking through tradeoffs between two or three agencies side by side.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many agencies should we put through a full RFP process?
Three is usually enough to compare meaningfully without turning the process into a part-time job for whoever's running it. Do a lighter first pass, a short call and a sample of past work, with a longer list, then reserve the full RFP and reference checks for the finalists.
Is a lower price always a red flag in an agency RFP?
Not automatically, but ask what's excluded to get there. A lower quote usually means fewer revision rounds, less senior staff time, or reporting handled less often, any of which can be a fine tradeoff depending on what you actually need, as long as you know that's the trade you're making.
Should we require the agency to guarantee performance in the contract?
Be wary of any agency willing to guarantee a specific result, since so much depends on your product, offer, and audience, not just the creative itself. A more useful commitment is a defined process for reviewing underperforming assets and reworking them within an agreed window.
Sources
Where we quote a benchmark, we show its source. Other figures in this guide are estimates or general guidance, so check them against your own numbers.
- Google Ads Average CPC (All Industries). WordStream 2025 Google Ads Benchmarks, 2024-2025.
Related Guides
Where Conversion Rate Benchmarking Actually Leaks Marketing Budget
The specific comparisons that reveal wasted marketing spend, and why comparing your conversion rate to the wrong benchmark hides the leak instead of finding it.
Why Creative Testing Slows Down Exactly When You Need It Most
The bottlenecks that make ad creative testing slow down as a program grows, and how to keep shipping variants without cutting corners on what each test teaches.
How to Run a Marketing Performance Audit Before a Board Meeting
A five-step way to check marketing spend, conversion rate and creative performance before a board meeting, so you present numbers you can defend.
An SEO Audit for Terms Your Competitors Already Rank For
A practical audit for winning search positions your competitors currently hold, covering content gaps, technical blockers and link signals.
Tracking Event and Webinar Leads All the Way to Revenue
A step-by-step process for tracking webinar and field event leads through the pipeline, so you know which events are actually worth repeating.
A Content Syndication Checklist for Reach Beyond Your Own Site
What to check before syndicating content to partner sites and aggregators, including canonical tags, timing and which pieces are worth spreading.