Product-Led Growth (PLG) & User ActivationPlaybook3 min readUpdated September 2026

Setting a Sales and Marketing SLA That Both Sides Actually Keep

A lot of sales and marketing SLAs get written once, in a planning meeting, with numbers that sound reasonable and get ignored within a quarter because nobody checked whether either side could actually hit them consistently.

Here's how to set terms that hold up, based on what your own recent numbers say is realistic, and what to do when one side starts missing them.

Vendors Covered in this Article

Disclosure: We may earn a commission if you buy through some links on this page. It doesn't change what we recommend.

How do you set lead volume commitments in a sales and marketing SLA?

Marketing's side of the SLA usually covers volume and quality of leads handed to sales: how many qualified leads per month, meeting a defined bar for fit and engagement. Set this number from your actual recent performance, not from what the revenue plan requires marketing to produce, since a target based purely on need rather than on demonstrated capacity sets the whole agreement up to fail from day one.

If the plan genuinely requires more volume than marketing has recently produced, that's a real conversation about budget, channels, or timeline, not something an SLA number can paper over by simply being written higher.

How fast should sales follow up on a marketing lead?

Sales's side typically covers how quickly a qualified lead gets a first follow up attempt. Set this based on your team's actual current capacity and process, not an aspirational number pulled from what a much larger sales org might achieve. A follow up commitment that's routinely missed erodes trust in the whole agreement faster than a more modest, consistently kept one does.

It's better to commit to a slower response time you'll actually hit every time than a faster one you'll hit half the time. Consistency is what makes the SLA meaningful to marketing's own planning; missed commitments, even fast ones on average, undermine that.

Define what happens when the lead definition itself is disputed

A common source of SLA breakdown isn't either side missing their number, it's disagreement about whether a specific lead actually met the qualification bar in the first place. Build a lightweight, defined process for flagging and reviewing disputed leads, rather than letting disagreement accumulate as informal frustration that eventually blows up in a planning meeting.

A simple weekly or biweekly review of a handful of disputed leads, with someone from each side present, tends to resolve this faster and with less friction than an unstructured complaint raised months later during a broader performance conversation.

For example, marketing hands over a lead who downloaded a comparison guide, and a rep rejects it as unqualified because the company is too small. Marketing believes it met the definition. Instead of arguing, both sides bring that lead to the weekly review and check it against the written criteria. If company size was never in the definition, add it. If it was, the lead should have been filtered earlier. Either way, the outcome is a clearer definition. The rule: settle each dispute by editing the shared definition, not by assigning blame to one team.

Review the actual numbers together on a regular cadence

Both sides should see the same real data on whether the SLA is being met, reviewed together on a set schedule, monthly is usually reasonable, rather than each side tracking their own version and disagreeing about whose numbers are right. Shared visibility into one accurate data source removes a lot of the friction that otherwise builds up around SLA compliance.

When one side is consistently missing their commitment, treat the first response as a process conversation, what's actually preventing the number from being hit, rather than an immediate renegotiation of the target. Sometimes the fix is operational, not a sign the target itself was wrong.

Revisit the terms twice a year, not just when something breaks

Set a standing time, twice a year is reasonable, to revisit the SLA terms deliberately, checking whether volume commitments still match current capacity and whether follow up speed commitments still make sense given team size and tooling. Waiting until something breaks to revisit the terms means you're always negotiating from a place of frustration rather than a calm, scheduled check-in.

An SLA that's never revisited quietly becomes disconnected from reality as both teams change size, tooling, and process over time, even if nobody explicitly decided to ignore it.

Treat the scheduled review as routine, not a sign something is wrong. Teams that only ever discuss the SLA when it's broken start to associate the conversation itself with conflict, which makes the whole agreement harder to maintain honestly over time.

A workable SLA includes these terms:

  • Marketing lead volume and quality targets set from recent actual performance, not from what the revenue plan requires.
  • A sales follow up speed commitment based on current team capacity, one you will hit every time rather than half the time.
  • A shared definition of a qualified lead, plus a defined process for reviewing disputed leads weekly or biweekly.
  • A monthly review of the same real data by both sides, treating a missed target as a process conversation first.
  • A standing review of the terms twice a year, held calmly rather than only when something breaks.
Executive Capability Standard

What Good Looks Like

A working sales and marketing SLA has targets both sides have actually hit consistently in the recent past, a defined process for disputed leads, and a shared data source both teams check together.

Building The Capability (5-Stage Skill Ladder)

1. Learn:Pull your last two quarters of actual lead volume and sales follow up speed, and compare them honestly against whatever informal expectations currently exist.
2. Do Manually:Write the SLA terms yourself based on that real data, including a simple process for flagging and reviewing disputed leads.
3. Delegate:Have a RevOps or marketing operations owner maintain the shared tracking and facilitate the regular review meeting between both teams.
4. Automate:Set up a shared dashboard both teams can see in real time, so SLA compliance doesn't depend on two separately maintained reports that occasionally disagree.
5. Buy:Bring in a fractional RevOps consultant, or ask Martha, MeetMyCMO's AI CMO, to help set realistic SLA targets from your actual historical performance.

How to Get Started

Disclosure: We may earn a commission if you buy through some links on this page. It doesn't change what we recommend.

ClickUp

ClickUp works well as the shared place to log and review disputed leads, so the process stays lightweight instead of turning into an email thread nobody can follow later.

Visit ClickUp→

Frequently Asked Questions

What should a sales and marketing SLA actually cover?

At minimum, two commitments: marketing's lead volume and quality target, and sales's follow up speed target. A clear, shared definition of what counts as a qualified lead, and a lightweight process for resolving disputes about specific leads, matter just as much as the numeric targets themselves.

What if marketing consistently can't hit the lead volume the revenue plan requires?

That's a signal to revisit the plan, the budget, or the channel mix directly, not to keep the SLA number set at an unrealistic level. An SLA target that both sides know is aspirational rather than achievable stops functioning as a real agreement and becomes a source of ongoing friction instead.

How do we handle disagreement about whether a specific lead was actually qualified?

Build a simple, regular review, weekly or biweekly, where a handful of disputed leads get looked at together by someone from each side. Resolving disagreements in small batches on a predictable schedule prevents them from accumulating into a larger, more contentious conversation later.

How often should SLA terms be renegotiated?

Set a standing review twice a year, separate from any moment when something is actively breaking. A scheduled, calm review tends to produce better adjustments than a renegotiation forced by frustration after a target has already been missed for several months running.

About the numbers

This guide doesn't quote a sourced benchmark. Figures in it are estimates or general guidance, so check them against your own numbers.

Related Guides