A Checklist for Reviewing a Marketing Agency Before You Renew
An RFP built from a generic template gets generic answers back, and a renewal decided on vibes instead of a scorecard tends to keep an underperforming agency around a year longer than it should have stayed. Both problems share the same fix: tie the evaluation to specific, checkable deliverables from the very start, not to how the meetings happen to feel.
The checklist below works equally well for a first RFP and for reviewing an agency you're already paying every month.
What the RFP should force them to show
Ask for a work sample from a client in your actual category, not a polished generic case study built to impress in a pitch deck. Ask who on the roster will actually touch your account, by name, not by title, since the senior team that runs the pitch is rarely the same junior team that runs the day-to-day work afterward once the contract is signed. A finalist willing to name real names and show category-specific work is telling you far more than a slide describing their process ever will, and a finalist who dodges the question is telling you something too. Request a short trial project with a fixed scope if the finalists are close on paper; a two-week piece of real work separates a strong writer of proposals from a strong operator far faster than another round of calls.
A quarterly scorecard that catches drift mid-contract
Build the scorecard directly from the deliverables promised at signing, cadence, channels, and reporting format, and review it every quarter instead of waiting for the renewal conversation to finally notice things have slipped. A short, consistent checklist like this is a good starting point, reused every quarter so drift shows up as a trend rather than a surprise:
- Deliverables actually shipped versus what the contract promised
- Reporting cadence: on time, complete, and readable without a follow-up call to explain it
- Senior staff continuity since signing, not just at kickoff
- Response time on requests outside the standing cadence
- Whether strategy has adapted to anything that's genuinely changed in your business
Scoring the work itself, not just the relationship
A friendly agency contact can mask work that isn't actually performing as well as the meetings suggest. If landing pages are part of the scope, compare the agency's own conversion rate against the all-industry median of 6.6%1 before assuming the relationship is fine simply because the meetings are pleasant and everyone likes each other. A scorecard built only around communication quality will miss a real performance problem for months, sometimes long enough that fixing it costs more than switching would have.
The renewal conversation itself
Ask directly what the agency would change about the engagement if you let them, and whether the senior people who actually won the pitch are still the ones assigned to the account today. Both questions tend to surface honest answers faster than asking generically how things are going, since that question invites a pleasant, noncommittal reply. An agency that can't answer either one specifically, or answers vaguely on purpose, is giving you a signal worth weighing seriously before you sign another year.
When to walk, and how to transition cleanly
Confirm the contract's actual notice period before you start the exit conversation, not after, and settle asset ownership in writing well ahead of time: who owns the ad accounts, the tracking setup, and the creative files if the relationship ends. Build in an overlap month with a new agency wherever the budget allows it, since a clean, overlapping handoff protects performance far more reliably than a hard cutover where nobody is minding the campaigns for a week or two.
The reference call that actually reveals something
A reference the agency hand-picked will say pleasant things almost by definition, so find your own instead: search for a client who's been with the agency for at least a year, ideally in a comparable industry, and ask what a first-time client should know before signing that nobody tells you upfront. Ask specifically about a time the agency dropped the ball and how they handled it, since every agency worth hiring has had at least one, and how they responded says more about the partnership than a perfect track record would.
What Good Looks Like
Good agency management means every deliverable in the contract gets checked on a real cadence, not just discussed pleasantly, and the renewal decision comes from that record rather than from how the meetings feel.
Building The Capability (5-Stage Skill Ladder)
How to Get Started
Frequently Asked Questions
How many agencies should we include in an RFP?
Say you're evaluating agencies for a meaningful monthly retainer; three to five finalists is usually enough for a real competitive process without turning the search itself into a quarter-long project that delays hiring anyone.
What's a fair notice period before switching agencies?
It depends entirely on what your specific contract says, so read the actual termination clause rather than assuming a standard. If your contract calls for a sixty-day notice period, for example, start the RFP with that runway built into the timeline.
Should the person who ran the RFP also score the renewal a year later?
Ideally someone stays involved for continuity, but add at least one fresh reviewer each cycle. A single owner across years can develop blind spots toward an agency they originally selected and want to have been right about.
Sources
Where we quote a benchmark, we show its source. Other figures in this guide are estimates or general guidance, so check them against your own numbers.
- Landing Page Conversion Rate (Median, All Industries). Unbounce Conversion Benchmark Report.
Related Guides
A Marketing Agency RFP Scorecard You Can Actually Use
A practical scorecard for evaluating marketing agency RFPs: what to ask before the pitch, how to score the meeting fairly, and what to check with references.
The Clauses That Actually Matter in a Creator Contract
A checklist of the contract clauses that most often cause problems in creator and influencer partnerships, and the mistakes to avoid when negotiating them.
What a Good Affiliate Landing Page Conversion Rate Looks Like
How to set a realistic conversion rate benchmark for creator and affiliate landing pages, and where to look first when a page underperforms.
Tracking Whether an Event or Webinar Actually Pays Off
How to build a simple worksheet that tracks event and webinar pipeline from attendee to closed deal, so you know which ones are worth repeating.
What Belongs on a Creator Program Dashboard for Leadership
What belongs on an executive dashboard for a creator program: the few numbers that drive budget decisions, and what to leave off so leadership stays focused.
A Marketing Agency RFP That Actually Screens for Fit
How to structure an agency RFP and review process so you're comparing real capability and fit, not just polished pitch decks and case studies.