A Marketing Agency RFP Scorecard You Can Actually Use
Most agency RFPs get scored on gut feel dressed up as a spreadsheet. Everyone remembers the agency with the best deck, and the scorecard quietly rearranges itself to justify the decision the room already made.
A scorecard only works if you fill it out before the pitch, not after, and if the categories are specific enough that two people scoring the same agency land in roughly the same place.
What to Ask Before You Ever See a Deck
Send these questions in writing before the pitch meeting, and score the written answers separately from the presentation. A polished pitch and a well-run account are different skills, and RFPs tend to reward the first one.
- Who specifically will work on our account, by name and role, not just the agency's leadership bios?
- Can we talk to a current client in a similar industry or size range, and one who left in the past year?
- What does a normal reporting cadence look like, and can we see a real example, not a template?
- Is any part of the work subcontracted, and if so, which part?
That last question matters more than it looks. An agency that subcontracts paid media or creative to a third party isn't necessarily worse, but you deserve to know before you're three months in and discover the person running your ad account isn't actually on their payroll, and has never sat in on one of your calls.
Scoring the Pitch Without Letting the Best Presenter Win
Have every person in the room score independently, on paper, before anyone talks. Group discussion before scoring almost always drifts toward whoever spoke first or most confidently, and that person isn't always right about the agency's actual fit.
Weight the categories that predict a working relationship over the ones that predict a good meeting: understanding of your specific business over general marketing knowledge, a realistic first ninety days over a flashy long-term vision, and clear answers to hard questions over confident answers to easy ones.
If an agency can't explain what they'd do differently for your specific product versus a generic company in your industry, that's worth noting even if the rest of the pitch was strong. It usually means the strategy slide was built from a template, not from research on you. Ask them to point to the one slide that couldn't be reused for a different client next week.
Reference Calls That Actually Tell You Something
A reference an agency hand-picks will say good things. Get past that by asking questions that require a specific answer rather than a general endorsement.
- Tell me about a time the agency missed a deadline or a target. How did they handle it?
- What do you wish you'd asked them before signing?
- If your budget doubled tomorrow, would you give it to this agency, or would you want to bring in a second one?
That last question is the most honest one on the list. A client who'd split new budget with someone else is telling you something a glowing testimonial won't.
Setting the First Ninety Days as the Real Trial Period
Write down what success looks like at day ninety before the contract is signed, not after the first invoice arrives. Vague goals like improve our marketing give both sides room to disagree later about whether the engagement is working.
Structure the first quarter as an explicit checkpoint rather than assuming the relationship will just continue. Some agencies are strong at long-term brand work but slow to show early wins, and some are the reverse. Knowing which one you hired changes what you should expect to see by the ninety-day mark.
Put the checkpoint conversation on the calendar when you sign, not when a problem shows up. A scheduled review feels routine. An unscheduled one feels like a warning, and agencies tend to get defensive rather than useful when it's the second kind. Bring the day-ninety success criteria back out at that meeting and score against it honestly, rather than letting the conversation drift into a general status update.
What Good Looks Like
Good agency evaluation means the scoring happens on paper before the room discusses it, references are asked specific questions instead of general ones, and success at ninety days is defined before the contract is signed.
Building The Capability (5-Stage Skill Ladder)
How to Get Started
Frequently Asked Questions
How many agencies should we invite to an RFP?
Three is usually enough to compare fairly without turning the process into a part-time job. More than four or five tends to produce shallower questioning of each one and a longer timeline before you can actually start working with someone.
Should pricing be part of the initial RFP or a separate conversation?
Ask for a pricing range up front so you're not wasting time on agencies outside your budget, then negotiate specifics after you've narrowed to a finalist. Full pricing before you've decided on fit tends to anchor the decision on cost alone.
What's a reasonable notice period to build into the contract?
Thirty to sixty days is common and gives both sides room to exit without stranding a campaign mid-flight. Avoid anything that locks you in for a full year with no earlier off-ramp, especially for a first engagement with an agency you haven't worked with before.
About the numbers
This guide doesn't quote a sourced benchmark. Figures in it are estimates or general guidance, so check them against your own numbers.
Related Guides
A Checklist for Reviewing a Marketing Agency Before You Renew
What to ask for in an agency RFP, how to build a quarterly scorecard from the contract, and questions that separate a real partner from a comfortable one.
How to Run a Marketing Agency RFP That Actually Finds a Fit
A checklist for evaluating marketing agencies beyond the pitch deck: what to ask references, how to score proposals fairly, and the traps to avoid.
A Marketing Agency RFP That Actually Screens for Fit
How to structure an agency RFP and review process so you're comparing real capability and fit, not just polished pitch decks and case studies.
A Conversion Rate Benchmarking Checklist That Holds Up
Six checks to run before you compare your conversion rate to a benchmark, so the comparison actually tells you something useful.
A Marketing Agency RFP That Tests Real Work, Not Pitches
How to run an agency RFP or review that compares real deliverables against your own data, plus the red flags that show up before you sign anything.
Deciding Which Martech Tools Actually Need to Talk to Each Other
A decision guide for deciding which tools in your marketing stack need a real integration, and which are fine staying manually connected.