Marketing Strategy & OperationsTemplate3 min readUpdated September 2026

Post-Purchase Review Request Email: Copy and Rules

A good post-purchase review request is short, arrives after the customer has used the product, and makes leaving a review a one-click action. Ask every customer, not just the happy ones, and never tie a reward to a positive rating. Below are two templates and the rules that keep the program honest.

Reviews influence buying decisions and are also regulated. The FTC has adopted a rule aimed at fake and manipulated reviews, and review platforms have their own policies. Keep your process clean from the start.

Vendors Covered in this Article

Disclosure: We may earn a commission if you buy through some links on this page. It doesn't change what we recommend.

What should a review request email say?

Keep it to a few lines: thank the customer, ask one question, and provide one link or star selector.

Template A, product review:

  • Subject: How's the [product name] working out?
  • Opening: Hi [first name], thanks for ordering the [product]. It's been [a few weeks] since it arrived.
  • Ask: Would you take a minute to tell other shoppers how it's going? Your honest opinion, good or bad, helps.
  • Button: Leave a review.
  • Close: If something isn't right, reply to this email and we'll help.

Template B, star-first: show five stars in the email so a click on a star opens the review form with that rating pre-filled. That reduces friction, but make sure customers can change the rating and that all ratings, low ones included, get posted.

How should you word the subject line and preview?

Write the subject line as a question or a simple request, and refer to the purchase by name.

Works well in practice:

  • "How's your [product] working out?"
  • "Quick question about your order"
  • "Would you review [product]?"

Avoid urgency tricks, ALL CAPS, and promises of rewards in the subject line. Use a real sender name and a reply address that's monitored, since customers sometimes answer with a problem rather than a review. Test two subject lines on comparable segments and judge them by the number of reviews submitted, not opens, which can be inflated by privacy features.

Can you offer an incentive for reviews?

Be careful. Offering a reward can be allowed in some cases, but it can't depend on the review being positive, and you generally need to make the incentive clear. The FTC's rule on consumer reviews also addresses buying positive reviews and suppressing negative ones. Review platforms such as Google have their own policies about incentivized and filtered reviews.

The safest approach is no incentive, or a small thank-you offered to all reviewers regardless of rating and disclosed. Never ask only customers who reported being happy, and never delete honest negative reviews just because they're negative. Ask your attorney to review your incentive and moderation policy, particularly if you sell in more than one country.

How to handle the replies and negative reviews

Route replies to a person. If a customer writes back with a problem, treat it as a support ticket first. Fix the issue, and afterward they may update their review on their own.

Respond publicly to negative reviews, politely and specifically. Acknowledge the issue, say what you've done or will do, and offer a way to reach you. Don't argue, and don't pressure someone to remove a review.

Only remove reviews that violate your published moderation rules, such as profanity, personal information, or content unrelated to the product, and apply those rules equally to positive and negative reviews. Tools like Okendo and Yotpo include moderation and reply features; check how they handle requests and moderation before choosing.

How to measure whether your requests work

Track these numbers by product category and by flow:

  1. Request-to-review rate: reviews submitted divided by requests delivered.
  2. Average rating and the share of reviews with photos or written text.
  3. Time from delivery to review.
  4. Unsubscribes and complaints on the request email.
  5. Product page conversion for items with reviews compared with items without.

If the request-to-review rate is low, look at timing next; see the best time to send a review request. If it's low across products, shorten the email and cut steps in the review form. Also compare with lifecycle emails like your win-back campaign so customers don't get several asks in a week.

Executive Capability Standard

What Good Looks Like

Every buyer gets one honest review request after delivery, all ratings are published under a published moderation policy, and replies to the request reach a person.

Building The Capability (5-Stage Skill Ladder)

1. Learn:Read the review policies of the platforms where your reviews appear, and note their rules on incentives and moderation.
2. Do Manually:Export recent orders, send the two-template request after delivery, and log reviews collected and issues raised.
3. Delegate:Give a customer experience lead ownership of the request flow, the reply inbox, and the moderation policy.
4. Automate:Trigger the request from delivery events in your store platform, with one reminder and suppression for support cases.
5. Buy:Adopt a reviews platform that handles requests, moderation, and syndication of reviews to search and shopping listings.

How to Get Started

Disclosure: We may earn a commission if you buy through some links on this page. It doesn't change what we recommend.

Frequently Asked Questions

When should I send a review request email?

After the customer has had time to use the product, and preferably triggered from a delivery confirmation instead of the order date. The right wait depends on the product, so test timing by category and see which produces more reviews.

Is it okay to only ask happy customers for reviews?

No. Selectively asking satisfied customers or filtering out unhappy ones can mislead shoppers and may violate regulations and platform rules. Send the request to everyone who bought, and post honest reviews regardless of rating.

Can I offer a discount for leaving a review?

It's risky. Incentives can't depend on the review being positive and often need to be disclosed, and some platforms restrict them. A simple approach is to skip incentives or offer the same small thank-you to all reviewers. Check with your attorney.

How many review requests should I send per order?

One request and at most one reminder a week or so later. More than that annoys customers and can raise complaints. Skip the reminder for customers who've opened a support ticket about the order.

About the numbers

This guide doesn't quote a sourced benchmark. Figures in it are estimates or general guidance, so check them against your own numbers.

Related Guides