When to Send a Review Request, by Product Type
Send a review request after the customer has had enough time with the product to form an opinion, counted from delivery rather than the order date. Fast-to-judge items like apparel need a short wait, while products whose value shows up over weeks, such as skincare or supplements, need longer. Test by category, because no universal number holds.
Most stores use one delay for everything, which means some customers are asked before they've opened the box and others after they've forgotten the purchase. A small amount of segmentation fixes that.
Vendors Covered in this Article
Disclosure: We may earn a commission if you buy through some links on this page. It doesn't change what we recommend.
When is the best time to ask for a review?
Ask when the customer can answer honestly. Ask too early, and reviews are thin ("arrived fast") or missing. Ask too late, and the excitement has faded and reply rates fall.
The question to ask for each product is: how long until a typical customer knows whether it works? For a t-shirt, that's the first wear. For a mattress topper, a week or two of sleep. For a supplement or skincare product, it may be several weeks of use.
Use those judgments as starting points for your first tests, not as findings. Your customers, shipping times, and product mix will decide what works.
How to set the delay by product type
Start with categories and adjust from results:
- Fast-judged items (apparel, accessories, simple home goods): a few days after delivery.
- Items that need setup or assembly (furniture, appliances, electronics): after the customer has had time to install and use them, often one to two weeks.
- Consumables where results build gradually (skincare, supplements, pet food): several weeks, so the customer has seen an outcome.
- Gifts: ask later, or ask the buyer about the purchase experience in place of the product, since the recipient may not be the buyer.
- Subscriptions: after the second or third shipment, once the customer has a real view of the product.
Always start the clock from the delivery confirmation event, not from the order date, so a delayed shipment doesn't get a request before the product arrives.
How do you test timing properly?
Run a simple split test within each category.
- Choose two delays for a category, such as one that's short and one that's longer.
- Randomly assign incoming orders to each delay.
- Keep the email content and the review form identical.
- Run it until each group has a meaningful number of orders, and for at least a few weeks.
- Compare reviews submitted per delivered request, plus review length and photo rate.
Judge by reviews collected, not by opens. Also look at review quality: a longer delay may produce fewer reviews but more detailed ones. Tools such as Okendo and Yotpo let you schedule requests relative to delivery, so check that your platform can apply a different delay per product or collection.
Time of day and day of week
Send time matters less than the delay after delivery, but it's worth a small test. Compare a morning send with an evening send, and weekday with weekend, using the same delivery-based delay.
Mobile is where most review requests get answered, so make sure the review form works on a phone and that a star click can start the review. If you also ask by text message, follow consent rules for SMS and keep it to a single short message; ask your attorney about requirements in your markets.
Avoid stacking asks. If a customer is also receiving a shipping update, a cross-sell, and a survey the same week, space them apart. For the email copy itself, see the review request email template.
Reminders and what to do when there's no response
Send at most one reminder, about a week after the first request, and only to people who haven't opened the review form. Change the wording, perhaps by asking a single question about the product, since a repeated identical email is more likely to be ignored.
Don't chase customers who've contacted support about the order until the issue is resolved. After the reminder, stop. Ask again only when there's a new purchase.
Each quarter, review the request-to-review rate by category and adjust the delay for underperformers. Products with few reviews benefit most, so consider a longer window and a follow-up email for them.
What Good Looks Like
Review requests are triggered from delivery events, delayed by product category, limited to one reminder, and tuned by testing reviews collected per delivered request.
Building The Capability (5-Stage Skill Ladder)
How to Get Started
Disclosure: We may earn a commission if you buy through some links on this page. It doesn't change what we recommend.
Fits Shopify stores that want review requests scheduled relative to delivery, with different delays by product.
Fits stores that want to time requests across email and SMS from one scheduler.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long after delivery should I ask for a review?
It depends on how quickly customers can judge the product. Fast-judged items may need only a few days, while products with gradual results need weeks. Start from delivery confirmation, test two delays per category, and keep the one that produces more reviews.
Should I start the timer at order date or delivery date?
Delivery date. Starting at the order date risks asking before the product arrives, especially with slow or delayed shipping. Use carrier delivery events, and add a small buffer for the customer to try the product.
How many reminders should I send?
One reminder is enough, about a week after the first request, sent only to those who didn't open the review form. Skip customers with open support issues. More reminders raise unsubscribe and complaint rates without adding many reviews.
Does time of day affect review request response?
Possibly, but less than the delay after delivery. Test morning against evening and weekday against weekend on your own customers. Make sure the review form works well on mobile, because many customers respond from a phone.
About the numbers
This guide doesn't quote a sourced benchmark. Figures in it are estimates or general guidance, so check them against your own numbers.
Related Guides
Post-Purchase Review Request Email: Copy and Rules
Two review request email templates, subject lines, what to ask, and the review rules to follow so your requests stay honest and compliant.
Yotpo vs Okendo for Ecommerce DTC: Customer Reviews & Social Proof Compared
Compare Yotpo and Okendo for Shopify DTC brands: review collection rates, photo/video UGC widgets, loyalty rewards, site speed, and conversion rate lift.
B2B Demo Request Page: Section-by-Section Copy Outline
A section-by-section outline for a B2B demo request page: headline, proof, form fields, expectations and follow-up, with sample copy you can adapt.
A Checklist for Reviewing a Marketing Agency Before You Renew
What to ask for in an agency RFP, how to build a quarterly scorecard from the contract, and questions that separate a real partner from a comfortable one.
Bazaarvoice vs Yotpo vs Okendo: Customer Reviews & UGC Platforms Compared
Compare Bazaarvoice, Yotpo, and Okendo for customer reviews, UGC syndication, visual social proof, retail distribution, and ecommerce conversion lift.
A Scorecard for Choosing a Marketing Agency (and Firing the Wrong One)
A scorecard-based process for evaluating marketing agency proposals, the questions that expose a weak fit, and setting a 90-day review.